You Might Be the Killer

Fran Kranz Sam

Alyson Hannigan Chuck

Brittany S. Hall Imani

Jenna Harvey Jamie

Bryan Price Steve ('The Kayak King')

Patrick Walker Brad

Jack Murillo Freddie

Sara Catherine Bellamy Drew

Savannah DesOrmeaux Nancy

Carol Jean Wells Heather

Peter Jaymes Jr. Bob

O

Olivia Jaye Brown Carol