A Nice Girl Like You

Lucy Hale Lucy Neal

Leonidas Gulaptis Grant Anderson

Mindy Cohn Priscilla Blum

Jackie Cruz Nessa Jennings

Adhir Kalyan Paul Goodwin

Stephen Friedrich Jeff Thayer

Deborah S. Craig Renee Lowell

Leah McKendrick Honey Parker

Constantine Maroulis DJ

Shiva Kalaiselvan Morgana

Angela Oh Fearful Woman

Matt Crabtree Groom