Garfunkel and Oates

Riki Lindhome Garfunkel

Kate Micucci Oates

Mike Phirman Rule 34 Announcer

Natasha Leggero Vivian

Michelle Zamora Puppeteer

Sarah Burns Cheryl

Busy Philipps Karen

Rich Fulcher Dr. Patel

Artemis Pebdani Janice

Creed Bratton Kazoo Man

Ben Kingsley Ben Kingsley

Sugar Lyn Beard Epiphany